All about apples, pears, plums, and cherries - and orchards where they are grown

Winter Banana apple

Last updated 10 Nov 2012.

Rate this variety for flavor

Current rating: 4.0 out of 5. Total votes cast: 10

Visitor comments

(Use the form at the bottom to add your own comments about this variety)

18 Nov 2014 
Just got some of these from Scott Farm in Vermont. They definitely have a subtle banana flavor and aroma. Scott Farm does a fantastic job growing and marketing heirloom varieties. These apples were free of blemishes and rust.

28 Jul 2013 
The house we moved into when I was a child had two of these trees, which produced a bumper crop of delicious apples yearly until fifteen years later when they were taken out by a lightning storm. No banana flavor/smell, but very sweet, dense flesh, light pineapple tones, PERFECT for apple pies and eating fresh, in my opinon. Stores great in the freezer, and if you keep them in cooler temps they store for four to five months easy. I will be planting two if I can find them - wonderful apple.

07 Apr 2013 
winter banana is named for the color and the ridges running up the sides, that resemble those on a banana. Late ripening, and a very orderly growth habit, requires little pruning.

26 Jan 2013 
I was pleasantly surprised by this apple: pretty fair for eating. I didn't get any banana overtones which is fine with me as I can't stand bananas!

05 Oct 2011 
These are the best apples. The flavor--weather they taste like bananas or not--is fabulous. They're big, they're great for fresh eating or cooking, and they keep if kept cold. Love them. My neighbor has a beautiful old tree and I hope to add one to my orchard this year.

22 Sep 2011 
Rauchtown, PA has the winter banana apple ... if were close

24 Jul 2011 
As a child living in Massachusetts, I remember my family would pack up and head off to apple orchards during the colder months of the year. One time we ended up at this apple orchard in New Hampshire and I tried an apple I never heard of. It was named "Winter Banana: but I do not remember it tasting like banana. To me it was more like pineapple and was a favorite of mine (only found this one time). I would be interested in knowing if it is available within a 100 mile radius of S. PA (near York, PA). Maybe I will grow it if I have room after my 2012 order is planted. Thanks!

21 Jan 2011 
You can find Winter Banana Apples (for shipment within the continental US only) at

21 Jan 2011 
where can I buy a winter banana apple tree?

28 Oct 2010 
Where can I purchase a Winter Banana Tree?

24 Sep 2010 
I have worked at an apple orchard for many years, I always thought it was a "ficticious" name for an apple that is used here for pollinating only.

14 Sep 2010 
I've been eating this apple since I was a child. I don't know where the banana comes from , maybe the color? They keep till spring if refrigerated. My very favorite!

15 May 2010 
Certain pear varieties can be grafted onto this. Apple-and-pear trees were available at one time from Deacon's nursery, i.o.w.

17 Aug 2009 
I find winter banana to be a much better cooking than eating apple. The flesh is very dense. I think it is one of the most beautiful apples in our orchard, but not the best eating apple.

06 May 2009 
I have tasted this tree in the 60's and 70's till the tree had been taken down. It was very old. We had 4 different types of apple trees. Our family house had been built in 1790, and there was an orchard with over 500 apple trees just above our house during that same time period. It truly tasted like a banana, and was yellow in color. I wish to taste one once again.

14 Nov 2008 
This is one of my favorite apples in our orchard, for its sweetness and unique flavor. Although I wouldn't necessarily peg the flavor as "banana" these apples do have an aromatic perfume that is unlike most others. I have been rehabilitating several 80 year old trees of this cultivar after decades of neglect, and they are beginning to bear nicely on renewed fruit spurs. The fruit itself is very attractive, a warm yellow color with red blemishes on one side. Crisp and never mealy, this is an apple to eat right off the tree! Perhaps the connotation of 'Banana' also comes from its yellowish color?

Add your comments about this variety

Have you tasted this variety ? Do you agree or disagree with our tasting notes ? Enter your comments below. Please tell us your name (just first name if you wish) and email address, and if possible the nearest city. Your name and location, but not your email address, may be published on this website. All comments are reviewed before publishing.

Your email
City (optional)
State (optional)
Password Create a password for your account
Organisation (optional)
Security question: What is the 1st or 2nd word of the name of this website (in big letters in the banner of this page)?
We send 2-3 newsletters per year, please let us know if you would like to receive them. Rest assured that we do not buy or sell email addresses - for more details see our privacy policy.

Named for the alleged banana-like flavour.

Winter Banana phototape


  • Species: Malus domestica
  • Parentage: Unknown
  • Originates from: Indiana, United States
  • Introduced: 1870s
  • Orange Pippin Cultivar ID: 1204
  • UK National Fruit Collection accession: 1921-094
  • We are grateful to Brogdale Farm - home of the UK National Fruit Collection - for providing samples of this variety.


  • Flesh colour: White to Cream, pale yellow
  • Flesh colour: White to Greenish to Greenish Yellow
  • Fruit size: Medium
  • Fruit size: Large
  • Fruit size: Variable
  • Fruit size: Very large
  • Fruit shape: Flat-round
  • Fruit shape: Short-round-conical
  • Fruit shape: Round
  • Fruit shape: Round-conical
  • Fruit shape: Conical
  • Fruit shape: Long-conical
  • Fruit shape: Oblong-conical
  • Fruit shape: Oblong
  • Shape features (vertical view): Lop-sided, unequal sides, irregular
  • Shape features (vertical view): Oblique - slanted
  • Shape features (vertical view): Variable, dissimilar shapes
  • Shape uniformity: Lack Uniformity in size & shape
  • Bultitude apple group: 5. Yellow, smooth, sweet or acidic
  • Russet % coverage: Low
  • Basin russet: Little, light russet
  • Basin russet: Smooth, fine Russet
  • Basin russet: Usually Russet free


  • Uses: Eat fresh
  • Uses: Juice
  • Uses: Hard cider
  • Uses: Drying
  • Flavour quality: Good
  • Flavour style: Sweeter
  • Flavour style: Sweet/Sharp
  • Flavour style: Aromatic
  • Flavour style: Honeyed / Scented
  • Flavour style: Sharp / refreshing
  • Harvest period: Late season


  • Flowering period: Mid-Late season
  • Flowering group: 4
  • Fertility: Self-sterile
  • Ploidy: Diploid
  • Fruit bearing: Spur-bearer
  • Period of origin: 1850 - 1899


  • Climate suitability: Temperate climates
  • Chilling: Low-chill


  • Cedar apple rust  - Very susceptible

References and further reading about this variety

  • Cedar-Apple Rust  
    Author: Stephen Vann, University of Arkansas, Division of Agriculture (FSA7538)
    Rated as highly susceptible - control always needed where CAR is prevalent.

Winter Banana identification photos from official fruit collections

UK National Fruit Collection

©Crown Copyright more >
UK National Fruit Collection

Winter Banana identification photos from website visitors

Winter Banana apples
Winter Banana apples

Winter Banana
Winter Banana

Fruit tree register

Do you have a tree of this variety in your garden or orchard? If so please register the details here and contribute to our international register of fruit trees.

The following Winter Banana trees have been registered - click the name to view more details of each tree.

You can also view these trees on a map.

United States

United Kingdom





New Zealand


Latest Spring blossom records for this variety

2017 season

  • 27th March  2017  - tree owned by Jerry in Point Reyes Station, United States

2016 season

  • 10th March  2016  - tree owned by Jerry in Point Reyes Station, United States
  • 1st March  2016  - tree owned by Kenneth in NEWBERRY, United States

2015 season

  • 24th March  2015  - tree owned by Jerry in Point Reyes Station, United States

2014 season

  • 23rd May  2014  - tree owned by Mark in LEYBURN, United Kingdom
  • 14th April  2014  - tree owned by Pip in RYE, United Kingdom

2013 season

  • 15th May  2013  - tree owned by Pip in RYE, United Kingdom
  • 3rd April  2013  - tree owned by Libba in ALBUQUERQUE, United States

2012 season

  • May  2012  - tree owned by Johan in GENT, Belgium
  • 4th April  2012  - tree owned by Pip in RYE, United Kingdom

2011 season

  • May  2011  - tree owned by Kris in HOLDEN, United States
  • 21st April  2011  - tree owned by Pip in RYE, United Kingdom

2010 season

  • 10th May  2010  - tree owned by Johan in GENT, Belgium

2009 season

  • September  2009  - tree owned by Pip in RYE, United Kingdom
  • 18th April  2009  - tree owned by Dave in Camas, United States

Record your blossom dates in our Fruit Tree Register - more >>.

Latest harvest records for this variety

2017 season

  • 4th week September  2017  - tree owned by Jerry in Point Reyes Station, United States

2016 season

    2015 season

    • 3rd week October  2015  - tree owned by Dolores in CANANDAIGUA, United States
    • October  2015  - tree owned by Roger in MADISON HEIGHTS, United States

    2014 season

    • October  2014  - tree owned by Pip in RYE, United Kingdom

    2013 season

    • October  2013  - tree owned by Pip in RYE, United Kingdom
    • September  2013  - tree owned by Libba in ALBUQUERQUE, United States

    2012 season

    • 2nd week October  2012  - tree owned by George in WOODLAND, United States
    • October  2012  - tree owned by Pip in RYE, United Kingdom

    2011 season

    • October  2011  - tree owned by Kris in HOLDEN, United States
    • October  2011  - tree owned by Pip in RYE, United Kingdom

    2010 season

      2009 season

      • 2nd week September  2009  - tree owned by Dave in Camas, United States

      Where to buy trees

      The following fruit tree nurseries offer Winter Banana apple trees for sale:

      • Cummins Nursery
        United States  More >>

      Where to buy fresh fruit

      United Statesmap >

      United Kingdommap >

      Canadamap >

      Sign in | Register

      Varieties you viewed

      Top 10 Varieties

      Top 10 highest ranked varieties

      Top 10 most voted on varieties

      Our Top 10 most popular variety descriptions

      ©2015 Orange Pippin Ltd. All rights reserved.
      Website by: Amarsys and Black Twig
      You may not reproduce any of the content of this website without our express permission.
      We do not accept any liability for loss or damage incurred as a result of any errors in the content of this website.