All about apples, pears, plums, and cherries - and orchards where they are grown

Scarlet Surprise apple

This is an American variety, also known as Bill's Redflesh and Firecracker, and one of the most extreme examples of a red-fleshed apple variety.  The red tendency dominates this apple, with not only the skin and flesh but also the leaves, wood, and blossoms all having a very pronounced red stain to them.

The apples are fairly small, round-conical and often slightly elongated in shape, usually about two inches in diameter, and two and a quarter inches deep. The stalk is of medium length, fairly thick, in a shallow cavity, projecting beyond the base. The skin is wholly red and smooth, sometimes with pale dots (lenticels). The flesh is deep pink to red, soft, and tender; the juice is sweet and tart. The eye is closed and there is little or no cavity. The appearance is very similar to Almata (also American) and Huonville Crab (Australian). There are apples in most years, though there is some tendency to be biennial.

This apple is more acidic than most dessert varieties, having an intense sharp brisk flavour. It keeps in good condition for about a week. After this time the acidity declines and the apple begins to shrink slightly. After a fortnight the acidity is less pronounced, the taste is sweeter and the texture rather soft and doughy.

The tree is slender and partial tip-bearing. The blossom is wholly red, new leaves are bronze-coloured, and the wood is red-stained. The flowering period is extremely early; about 20 days earlier than Bramley. It is one of the first apple trees in the orchard to flower. It is a very poor pollinator. The tree grows rapidly and vigorously.

We are grateful to Nigel Deacon, an English apple enthusiast with a particular interest in red-fleshed apple varieties, for samples and background of this apple variety. There are details of many more red-fleshed apples on his website and he can supply / exchange seeds and scionwood - see Diversity website.

Description by: .   

USDA identification images for Scarlet Surprise

The identification paintings in the USDA Pomological Watercolor Collection span the years 1886 to 1942.

    Citation: U.S. Department of Agriculture Pomological Watercolor Collection. Rare and Special Collections, National Agricultural Library, Beltsville, MD 20705.

    Visitor reviews

    • 03 Dec 2012  VEJLE, Denmark
      You could try one of the new red-fleshed apples from Lubera - it is a series called Redlove.
    • 27 Nov 2012  LEICESTERSHIRE, United Kingdom
      Yes, this is the one registered by Stark Brothers. I prefer the name 'Scarlet Surprise' but it is known as Bill's Redflesh and (more recently) Firecracker in some circles. Until cut through it can't be readily distinguished from 'Almata' but the flesh colour is darker in most years.
    • 07 Jun 2011  GA, United States
      Stark Brothers lists both Scarlet Surprise and Bill's Red Flesh on the tags for this tree.
    • 14 May 2011  Australia
      Is this the same 'Scarlet Surprise' that is registered by Stark Brothers, or is it the unregistered one that is also known as 'Bill's Red Flesh' and 'Firecracker', and was introduced by either Bill Schulz or Oregon State University? Any clarification on this point is welcome!

    Tree register

    United States






    • Species: Malus domestica


    • Picking season: Early
    • Cropping: Good
    • Keeping (of fruit): 1 week
    • Flavor style (apples): Sharper
    • Food uses: Eating fresh
    • Food uses: Culinary
    • Discoloration of fruit: Very oxidising (browns quickly)


    • Attractive features: Attractive flowers
    • Self-fertility: Not self-fertile
    • Flowering group: 1
    • Ploidy: Diploid
    • Bearing regularity: Regular


    • Cold-hardiness: Cold-hardy
    • Summer average maximum temperatures: Cool ( 20-24C / 68-75F)
    • Summer average maximum temperatures: Warm (25-30C / 76-85F)


    • Country of origin: United States
    • Flower colour: Pink
    • Leaf colour: Bronze
    • Leaf colour - autumn: Bronze / Purple
    • Fruit size: Small
    • Fruit colour: Red

    Where to buy fresh fruit

    The following orchards grow Scarlet Surprise:

    United States

    Varieties you viewed

    ©2022 Orange Pippin Ltd. All rights reserved.

    You may not reproduce any of the content of this website without our express permission.
    We do not accept any liability for loss or damage incurred as a result of any errors in the content of this website.